Comparing AI tools: a business decision

Summary

Assisting Budget Officers to decide when and why to procure an AI license for their department faculty or staff.

Body

Audience: Chief Business Officers (CBOs), Department Chairs, Deans, Directors, Business Managers

Responsible Group: IT Training and Outreach

Overview

University leaders are responsible for stewarding limited financial resources while enabling staff to work efficiently and securely. This article outlines the return on investment (ROI) of purchasing licensed, enterprise-grade AI toolssuch as Microsoft Copilot and ChatGPT Edu for staff use. Based on industry research and conservative cost assumptions, licensed AI tools can return several thousand dollars per employee per year in recovered productivity, while also reducing compliance and security risks associated with unlicensed AI use.

Why It Matters

  • Productivity Gains – Licensed AI tools reduce time spent on reports, data analysis, presentations, curriculum planning, and grant writing. Studies show staff save hours each week when AI is embedded in their daily tools. Even small efficiency gains—measured in minutes per day—translate into significant annual savings.
  • Data Protection – Free or consumer-level AI tools do not meet FERPA or institutional compliance standards. Licensed tools ensure university data is not shared or used for model training.
  • Risk Reduction – Purchasing secure AI tools prevents shadow IT (unapproved personal accounts), which increases legal, financial, and reputational risk.
  • Institutional Competitiveness – AI literacy is a Forward 150 priority. Investing in compliant AI helps your staff stay ahead in research, instruction, and administration.
Tip: Think of AI licenses as both a productivity tool and an insurance policy. You enable your team to work smarter while protecting sensitive university data.

Documented Productivity Gains (Evidence-Based)

Microsoft’s Work Trend Index Special Report studied early enterprise AI users and found:

  • 70% of users reported being more productive

  • 29% faster completion of common tasks (searching, writing, summarizing)

  • 90 minutes saved per week for some role-specific use cases

  • Nearly 4× faster at catching up on missed meetings

  • 77% of users did not want to give up the tool after using it

These gains were observed inside existing workflows (Word, Outlook, Teams, Excel), not in experimental environments. SourceWhat Can Copilot’s Earliest Users Teach Us About Generative AI at Work? (from microsoft.com).

Key Benefits of Licensed AI Tools

Copilot for Microsoft 365

  • Integrated in Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Outlook, and Teams.
  • Leverages Microsoft Graph to securely access email, OneDrive, SharePoint, and calendar data.
  • Enterprise compliance posture – data stays in your M365 tenant.
  • Cost: $240 per user per year.
Why does Copilot for Microsoft 365 matter?

Microsoft 365 Copilot combines AI productivity with enterprise-grade privacy and compliance, making it a secure choice for higher education. It operates entirely within the Microsoft 365 boundary, inheriting existing user permissions through Microsoft Graph so it never exposes data users can’t already access. Prompts, files, and responses are not used to train large language models, and all activity is encrypted and logged for auditing. Copilot meets standards such as GDPR, ISO/IEC 27018, and the Microsoft Data Protection Addendum, with EU data residency controls where required. Features like Enterprise Data Protection (green shield icon) and administrator settings—including the ability to disable web searches—ensure sensitive institutional data stays protected. Licensing Copilot is both a productivity investment and a risk-management strategy: it enables staff to work more efficiently inside familiar tools like Word, Excel, Outlook, and Teams while safeguarding FERPA-protected and institutional data from the risks associated with consumer AI. Source:  Data, Privacy, and Security for Microsoft 365 Copilot

OpenAI ChatGPT Edu

  • FERPA-aligned platform for teaching, research, and administrative use.
  • Enterprise controls: SSO, admin dashboards, role-based policies.
  • Supports curriculum design, grant writing, data analysis, coding help, and policy drafting.
  • Cost: $120 per user per year (Standard) or $240 per user per year (Power User with Deep Research).
What security and privacy controls does ChatGPT Edu offer?

You own and control your business data in ChatGPT Enterprise. We do not train on your business data or conversations, and our models don’t learn from your usage. ChatGPT Enterprise is also SOC2 compliant and all conversations are encrypted in transit and at rest. Our new admin console lets you manage team members easily and offers domain verification, SSO, and usage insights, allowing for large-scale deployment into enterprise. See our privacy page and our Trust Portal for more details on how we treat your enterprise data. - Source: OpenAI

Return on Investment (ROI)

AI License ROI Snapshot
Factor Without License With License
Staff Efficiency Manual reporting, slower analysis, more admin burden Hours saved each week via drafting, analysis, automation
Data Security Risk of staff using personal/consumer AI tools Institutional compliance and FERPA alignment
Financial Risk Exposure to data breaches or policy violations Risk mitigation through licensed enterprise tools

Conservative ROI Calculation (Per Employee)

  • Fully loaded staff cost: $40,000/year
  • Approximate hourly cost: $20/hour
  • Time saved using licensed AI: 90 minutes/week
  • (Based on Microsoft Work Trend Index findings for early Copilot users)
  • Annual work weeks: 48

Recovered Productivity Value

  • 1.5 hours/week × 48 weeks = 72 hours/year
  • 72 hours × $20/hour = $1,440 per employee per year

Cost Comparison

  • Microsoft 365 Copilot license = $240 per user/year
  • Estimated productivity value = $1,440 per user/year

Net ROI (Per Employee)

  • $1,440 - $240 = $1,200 net value per employee per year
  • 6 x return on licensing cost

This calculation still excludes additional benefits such as:

  • Higher-quality first drafts (less rework)
  • Faster onboarding and knowledge transfer
  • Reduced meeting follow-up time
  • Risk mitigation from avoiding consumer AI tools
  • Compliance and data-protection safeguards
Department Level ROI
Staff Count Annual License Cost ($240/ per user/year) Estimated Productivity Value (at 40k annual salary) Net Gain
5 $1,200 $7,200 $6,000
12 $2,880 $17,280 $14,400
35 $8,400 $50,400 $42,000
One license pays for itself after approximately 12 hours of use per year. It is a low-cost, high-confidence investment with a short payback period.

What's next

Licenses must be purchased through university procurement. Faculty and staff will access these tools using their UARK credentials.

If interested in purchasing a license please submit a Request AI Tool form, found in the Related Services section. For more information about AI Tools, please review any of the linked articles in the Related Articles section. 

Contact IT Procurement (contract@uark.edu) for guidance on purchasing for your department or unit.

Support Resource

 AI Literacy & Data Responsibility Community of Practice

Need Help?

If this article needs to be updated, please leave feedback on this article and it will notify the owner of the article.

Details

Details

Article ID: 1258
Created
Fri 8/29/25 3:44 PM
Modified
Fri 1/23/26 3:37 PM

Related Articles

Related Articles (6)

Copilot chat comes with the Microsoft educational licenses that all @uark.edu account holders have. Learn about it, how to access, and training to get started.
About the AI tool Copilot for Microsoft 365 that is built directly into apps like Word, Excel, Outlook, and Teams and uses your work data for context, analysis, and answering prompts.
About the AI tool OpenAI ChatGPT Edu license that is available for departments, faculty, staff to purchase from IT Services.
Data residency is possible with the OpenAI ChatGPT Edu license.
Comparing Copilot chat, Copilot for Microsoft 365, and OpenAI ChatGPT Edu licenses: uses and cost.
Current active students, faculty, and staff are able to use their UARK accounts to log in and use Google AI tools, Gemini for Education (free tier) and NotebookLM with limited storage and abilities.

Related Services / Offerings

Related Services / Offerings (1)

Requests for AI Tools